Critical Analysis : The Script - "Break Even"

I like this song, a lot. It's very mellow and definitely one of those "the day is going really good so I'm going to sing obscure indie-pop-rock" songs. The melody is very smooth and the vocals are really relaxing. The song is very different from the music I prefer, but I see myself listening to it over and over again. I would totally say that the song deserves to be on VH1's top 20 videos. I just like the way the song sounds. Play it at parties, weddings, or just in the car when you feel great. If you're younger, it's definitely something you can listen to around your parents.

Quick Recap:
Very smooth melody
Catchy lyrics
Relaxing mood

All in all, I really want to check out more from this band now after watching the video. A+ grade :)

Video:

Critical Analysis : Justin Bieber - "Baby ft. Ludacris"

Ok. This song honestly wasn't bad, but it wasn't all that special either. The kid has a great singing ability (although they probably touch it up in the studio), but it seems he doesn't really use it all. It was a pretty generic r&b-teen pop song that lacked any real appeal in my opinion. Then again, most teen oriented songs don't. I also find it a little strange that a 16(13?)-year-old kid is making music of this type. I just don't get it. There's nothing wrong with him making this kind of music, nothing at all, but I would at least expect him to be some-what older before writing songs about how he wants some girl to be his "baby." I guess it has to appeal to an audience, and if cheesy love lyrics coupled with generic pop beats sells records, then so be it.

So quick summary:
Not bad, but not special
He has talent, but doesn't seem to use it all
Generic sound

I'll give the song a B- in actual terms of how good it is.

Video: